From Plow to Processor: Rethinking Critical Thinking in the Age of AI

Russell Hannon, author, acclaimed travel expert who uses lean principles to travel at a fraction of the going rate. and founder of "Break the Travel Barrier" left a comment on a recent RPM-Academy LinkedIn poll about how artificial intelligence (AI) has impacted formal exams to assess knowledge and skill transfer stopped me in my tracks:

"The paradigm is certainly shifting. However, it will always be fundamental to develop independent analysis/rationalization/problem solving, not to mention judgement as not to blindly believe what 'AI' tells you. After all, what if there is a blackout just when you need to figure something out?" - Russell Hannon

That last line—what if there is a blackout just when you need to figure something out?—echoed in my head like a warning bell. Not because it predicted an apocalyptic event, but because it reminded me of something older, simpler, and strangely relevant: a farmer, a horse, and a plow.

There was a time when managing a small farm required constant awareness, adaptability, and critical thought. The farmer needed to understand the soil, read the skies, track the seasons, and work in harmony with both beast and land. Then came mechanization. The tractor replaced the horse, and eventually, GPS-guided combines replaced the farmer’s intuitive steering. The yield improved. The labor changed. But so did the critical thinking. Not gone—just... different.

And now, here we are. A similar shift is unfolding, not in fields, but in every domain touched by data, decisions, and daily life. Artificial intelligence, perhaps referred to in the future as "augmented intelligence" or "collective cognition".

Are We Outsourcing Our Thinking?

The promise of AI—more convenience, faster access to knowledge, and support in solving problems—is undeniably powerful. But with each task we offload to a machine, we must ask: Are we still engaging our own minds in the process?... Is our capacity and capability for critical thinking expanding or... contracting?

This is not a Luddite lament. AI is not the enemy. But neither is it a thinking partner in the way many people assume. Artificial intelligence might be viewed as an optimizer, a mirror, sometimes a provocateur. But... does it "understand"? Does it feel doubt? Does it weigh ethics? Is it capable of lateral thinking?... When you consider that;

• Critical thinking is a systematic process of analyzing information, identifying biases, and forming well-reasoned judgments. It involves actively questioning, interpreting, evaluating, and making decisions based on evidence and sound reasoning

The Last Skill Standing

In a world of prompts and predictions, critical thinking might just be the last truly human skill. It’s not flashy. It doesn’t get taught with fanfare. But it’s the foundation of discernment, adaptability, and even empathy. And don't get me stated on curiosity... Curiosity and critical thinking are intertwined! Curiosity fuels the desire to explore and learn, while critical thinking provides the tools to analyze and evaluate that information.

What separates an insightful question from a superficial one? What keeps us from blindly trusting an answer, whether from Google, GPT, or a guru? It’s our ability to assess context, challenge assumptions, and see nuance. As AI grows more fluent, we must become more reflective.

The Learning Paradox

Ironically, the more powerful AI becomes, the more essential it is to remain committed to learning. Not rote memorization. Not trivia. But the kind of learning that builds cognitive muscle: logical reasoning, curiosity, creativity, judgment.

Here’s the paradox: AI can provide answers faster than ever—but the capacity to know what to ask, and what to do with the answer, is still entirely up to us.

And that’s where RPM-Academy can play a small but meaningful role.

Why Continuous Learning Matters More Than Ever

We don’t offer shortcuts. We offer something far more valuable: the tools to think clearly, act decisively, and adapt intelligently. Our courses aren’t just about Lean Six Sigma, Agile, or Innovation... technical skills, emotional intelligence, cognitive skills —they’re about building mental flexibility. About preparing for a world where yesterday’s solutions won’t solve tomorrow’s problems. AI may guide the plow now, but someone still needs to choose the field. So ask yourself;

• Are you preparing to co-exist with AI as a passive user—or as an active, thinking partner?

• Are you investing in your ability to navigate complexity—not just with data, but with discernment?

In the end, it’s not about fearing the blackout. It’s about being the one who can still think clearly when the lights go out.

Stay curious. Stay capable. And never stop learning!

SIGN UP FOR A FREE ACCOUNT